EVO ATLASEN中文
Atlas home / References / The palaeobiology of two crown group cnidarians: Haootia quadriformis and Mamsetia manunis gen. et sp. nov. from the Ediacaran of Newfoundland, Canada
References / paper

The palaeobiology of two crown group cnidarians: Haootia quadriformis and Mamsetia manunis gen. et sp. nov. from the Ediacaran of Newfoundland, Canada

McIlroy, D.; Pasinetti, G.; Pérez-Pinedo, D.; McKean, C.; Taylor, R.S.

Year2024
Source roleprimary-study
DOI / ID10.3390/life14091096

Fitness and scope

taxonomy · morphology · topology

Re-examines holotype NFM F-994 and plastotype OUM ÁT.424/p and supports a crown-staurozoan interpretation; the dossier retains the earlier anatomical objections.

Claim ledger

morphology · contested

Haootia preserves repeated aligned impressions in a tetraradial body, interpreted as muscle bundles and compared with Staurozoa, but fibre identity and detailed homology have competing primary assessments.

claim:event:haootia-muscle-interpretation
morphology · contested

Haootia preserves repeated aligned impressions in one Ediacaran holotype, but muscle identity, orientation and staurozoan comparison have competing primary interpretations; the specimen does not set a Staurozoa or Cnidaria range.

claim:taxon:haootia
fossil-range · contested

Haootia is displayed at approximately 560 Ma only as the age estimate for its type material used by competing muscular-cnidarian interpretations; it is not a crown-Staurozoa FAD, direct ancestor or global genus duration.

claim:taxon:haootia:range-boundary-rc50
taxonomy · contested

Haootia quadriformis is retained as an Ediacaran cnidarian candidate because the holotype was described in a muscular-cnidarian framework, while later primary studies dispute the staurozoan comparison and keep its precise placement open.

claim:taxon:haootia:taxonomy
biogeography · high

The Haootia holotype NFM F-994 comes from the Fermeuse Formation on the Bonavista Peninsula of Newfoundland, Canada; this named occurrence does not establish a complete geographic distribution or origin centre.

claim:taxon:haootia:biogeography
morphology · contested

The Haootia holotype preserves a roughly quadrate body impression with repeated aligned internal structures; muscle identity and their orientation remain competing interpretations rather than observed histology.

claim:taxon:haootia:morphology
Open source ↗DOI ↗